To consider the report of the head of legal and democratic on the appointment to those committees required to be politically balanced together with the together with the Climate Emergency Advisory Committee, the Licensing Acts Committee and joint committees.
Minutes:
Council considered the report of the head of legal and democratic on the appointment of those committees and joint committees which are required to be politically balanced; together with the Climate Emergency Advisory Committee, Licensing Acts Committee, and appointments to joint bodies.
The chair referred to the recommendations set out in the report, and circulated at the meeting, which covered the committee appointments for the 2024/25 municipal council year.
These recommendations were that Council:
1. appoints the committees and panels for the 2024/25 year and allocate seats to each political group as set out in the schedule circulated prior to the meeting;
2. appoints councillors and substitutes to sit on the committees and panels as set out in the schedule circulated prior to the meeting:
3. appoints councillors to the Licensing Acts Committee as set out in the schedule circulated prior to the meeting;
4. appoints councillors to the Climate Emergency Advisory Committee as set out in the schedule circulated prior to the meeting;
5. appoints chairs and vice-chairs as set out in the schedule circulated prior to the meeting;
6. appoints all local members representing the wards covered by the relevant area committees to those committees for the 2024/25 municipal year – Abingdon and North East, Faringdon and Wantage;
7. appointsPaul Barrow as the council’s representative and Ron Batstone as substitute on the Oxfordshire Joint Health Overview and Scrutiny Committee;
8. appoints Neil Fawcett as the council’s representative and Helen Pighills as substitute on the Thames Valley Police and Crime Panel;
9. appoints Emily Smith, Debby Hallett and Andy Cooke to the Future Oxfordshire Partnership Scrutiny Panel;
10. authorises the head of legal and democratic to make appointments to any vacant committee or panel seat and substitute positions in accordance with the wishes of the relevant group leader.
A number of councillors expressed concern that the independent councillors had no representation on committees and spoke in support of the Council making such provision. Other councillors noted that, as set out in the report, non-group councillors were not automatically entitled to committee seats. Such provision required no councillor voting against such a proposal and this was not guaranteed.
RESOLVED: That for the 2024/25 municipal year to:
1. appoint the following committees and panels for the 2024/25 municipal year and to appoint the membership, substitutes and chairs and vice-chairs as indicated to sit on them (see table below);
Planning Committee, 9 Members |
|
Green (1) |
|
Ron Batstone |
Cheryl Briggs |
Jenny Hannaby |
|
Scott Houghton |
|
Rob Maddison |
|
Mike Pighills |
|
Jill Rayner |
|
Val Shaw (Vice-Chair) |
|
Max Thompson (Chair) |
|
Preferred substitutes |
|
Liberal Democrat (8) |
Green (3) |
Paul Barrow |
Katherine Foxhall |
Robert Clegg |
Sarah James |
Andy Cooke |
Viral Patel |
Amos Duveen |
|
Oliver Forder |
|
Hayleigh Gascoigne |
|
Judy Roberts |
|
Emily Smith |
|
Green (1) |
|
Ron Batstone |
Katherine Foxhall (Chair) |
James Cox |
|
Eric de la Harpe |
|
Oliver Forder |
|
Hayleigh Gascoigne |
|
Debby Hallett |
|
Rob Maddison |
|
Judy Roberts (Vice-Chair) |
|
Preferred substitutes |
|
Liberal Democrat (8) |
Green (3) |
Paul Barrow |
Viral Patel |
Kiera Bentley |
Sarah James |
Robert Clegg |
Cheryl Briggs |
Andy Cooke |
|
Amos Duveen |
|
Jenny Hannaby |
|
Emily Smith |
|
Max Thompson |
|
Joint Scrutiny Committee, 5 Members |
|
Liberal Democrat (4) |
Green (1) |
Andy Cooke |
Katherine Foxhall (Co-Chair) |
Ron Batstone |
|
Judy Roberts |
|
Andrew Skinner |
|
Preferred substitutes |
|
Liberal Democrat (4) |
Green (3) |
Kiera Bentley |
Sarah James |
Mike Pighills |
Viral Patel |
Patrick O’Leary |
Cheryl Briggs |
Max Thompson |
|
Joint Audit and Governance Committee, 4 Members |
|
Liberal Democrat (4) |
|
Oliver Forder |
|
Judy Roberts |
|
Andrew Skinner |
|
Emily Smith (Co-Chair) |
|
Preferred substitutes |
|
Liberal Democrat (4) |
|
Andy Cooke |
|
Eric de la Harpe |
|
Jenny Hannaby |
|
Mike Pighills |
|
Community Governance and Electoral Issues Committee, 6 Members |
|||
Liberal Democrat (5) |
Green (1) |
||
Ron Batstone |
Sarah James |
||
Oliver Forder |
|
||
Diana Lugova |
|
||
Rob Maddison (Chair) |
|
||
Max Thompson (Vice-Chair) |
|
||
Preferred substitutes |
|||
Liberal Democrat (5) |
Green (3) |
||
Eric de la Harpe |
Cheryl Briggs |
||
Neil Fawcett |
Katherine Foxhall |
||
Scott Houghton |
Viral Patel |
||
Patrick O’Leary |
|
||
Mike Pighills |
|
||
Joint Staff Committee, 5 Members |
|
Liberal Democrat (4) |
Green (1) |
Mark Coleman |
Viral Patel |
Neil Fawcett |
|
Andy Foulsham |
|
Bethia Thomas |
|
Substitutes |
|
The Leader may be substituted by another Cabinet member. Other members of the committee may be substituted by any other member of the council. |
General Licensing Committee, 12 Members |
|
Liberal Democrat (11) |
Green (1) |
Paul Barrow |
Cheryl Briggs |
Ron Batstone (Chair) |
|
Kiera Bentley |
|
Lucy Edwards |
|
Neil Fawcett |
|
Oliver Forder |
|
Diana Lugova |
|
Patrick O’Leary (Vice-Chair) |
|
Val Shaw |
|
Andrew Skinner |
|
Bethia Thomas |
|
NO SUBSTITUTES |
Licensing Acts Committee, 12 Members |
|
Liberal Democrat (11) |
Green (1) |
Paul Barrow |
Cheryl Briggs |
Ron Batstone (Chair) |
|
Kiera Bentley |
|
Lucy Edwards |
|
Neil Fawcett |
|
Oliver Forder |
|
Diana Lugova |
|
Patrick O’Leary (Vice-Chair) |
|
Val Shaw |
|
Andrew Skinner |
|
Bethia Thomas |
|
NO SUBSTITUTES |
Appeals Panel, 3 Members |
Liberal Democrat (3) |
Paul Barrow |
Rob Clegg (Chair) |
Jill Rayner |
PREFERRED SUBSTITUTES |
Liberal Democrat (3) |
Mark Coleman |
Debby Hallett |
Val Shaw |
Climate Emergency Advisory Committee, 7 Members |
|
Liberal Democrat (6) |
Green (1) |
Kiera Bentley |
Sarah James |
Robert Clegg |
|
Eric de la Harpe (Vice Chair) |
|
Hayleigh Gascoigne (Chair) |
|
Scott Houghton |
|
Max Thompson |
|
Preferred substitutes |
|
Liberal Democrat (6) |
Green (3) |
Ron Batstone |
Viral Patel |
Amos Duveen |
Katherine Foxhall |
Rob Maddison |
Cheryl Briggs |
Mike Pighills |
|
Jill Rayner |
|
Val Shaw |
|
2. appoints all local members representing the wards covered by the relevant area committees to those committees for the 2024/25 municipal year – Abingdon and North East, Faringdon and Wantage;
Supporting documents: